Etsy, Inc. (NASDAQ: ETSY) has carved a unique niche in the e-commerce landscape, connecting millions of buyers and sellers through its marketplace for handmade, vintage, and craft items. Despite its distinct value proposition, Etsy has faced headwinds, including declining gross merchandise sales (GMS) and a challenging consumer spending environment. However, its strategic initiatives, robust profitability, and undervalued stock present a compelling case for a long position. This blog post analyzes the reasons to consider investing in Etsy, exploring its GMS challenges, the impact of the Reverb sale, shifting consumer trends, and the company’s long-term growth potential.
Understanding Etsy’s Business Model and Market Position
Etsy operates a two-sided marketplace that thrives on connecting creative sellers with buyers seeking unique, non-mass-produced goods. Unlike e-commerce giants like Amazon or Walmart, Etsy focuses on handcrafted, vintage, and artisanal products, appealing to consumers who value individuality and craftsmanship. Its asset-light model—no warehouses, no inventory risk, and no supply chain management—allows Etsy to maintain high gross margins, averaging around 71% in recent periods. This efficiency provides a strong foundation for profitability, even in the face of declining GMS.
The company generates revenue through transaction fees, advertising services, and payment processing, with a take rate that has climbed to approximately 23-24%. This high take rate offsets GMS declines, enabling revenue growth despite lower transaction volumes. Etsy’s niche positioning also shields it from direct competition with mass-market retailers, though it faces challenges from social commerce platforms like Pinterest and Meta, as well as broader e-commerce competitors like Shopify and eBay.
Navigating the GMS Decline
Etsy’s gross merchandise sales, the total value of goods sold on its platform, have been sliding, reflecting broader pressures on consumer discretionary spending. The decline in GMS is driven by reduced demand for handcrafted and gift items, a trend exacerbated by macroeconomic challenges such as inflation and cautious consumer behavior. Additionally, Etsy’s active buyer base has contracted slightly, with a reported drop in active buyers and per-buyer transaction value.
However, the GMS decline is not a death knell for Etsy’s investment case. The company has demonstrated resilience by improving its take rate and diversifying revenue streams. For instance, increased adoption of seller advertising services has bolstered services revenue, offsetting marketplace revenue declines. Furthermore, Etsy’s focus on enhancing user experience through mobile app improvements and AI-driven personalization aims to reverse GMS trends by boosting buyer engagement and order frequency. The mobile app, which accounts for a significant portion of GMS, is showing positive traction, with year-over-year growth in app-driven sales.
The GMS slide also reflects a normalization after Etsy’s pandemic-era boom, when GMS surged due to heightened online shopping. While the post-pandemic reversion to pre-COVID spending patterns has hurt growth, Etsy’s ability to maintain stable revenue and profitability suggests that the current GMS weakness may be a temporary hurdle rather than a structural flaw.
Strategic Refocus: The Reverb Sale and Back-to-Basics Approach
Etsy’s decision to sell Reverb, its musical instrument marketplace, marks a strategic pivot back to its core competency: the Etsy marketplace for handmade and vintage goods. The sale allows Etsy to streamline operations, reduce distractions, and allocate resources to high-impact initiatives within its primary platform. Reverb, while a unique offering, contributed only marginally to revenue and diluted management’s focus. By divesting it, Etsy can double down on its differentiated value proposition—curated, artisanal products—and strengthen its brand identity.
This back-to-basics approach aligns with Etsy’s efforts to address criticisms about platform quality. Some sellers and buyers have expressed frustration over the influx of mass-produced or dropshipped items, which dilute Etsy’s handmade ethos. Social media sentiment, particularly from small businesses and artists, highlights a desire for Etsy to return to its roots as a marketplace for authentic, crafted goods. By refocusing on its core marketplace and enforcing stricter seller standards, such as the introduction of a seller setup fee, Etsy aims to restore trust and enhance the platform’s appeal to its target audience.
Consumer Trends: Is the Era of Trinkets Declining?
Critics argue that the era of shopping for “trinkets”—small, discretionary, handcrafted items—is waning, as consumers prioritize essential spending amid economic uncertainty. This perception, coupled with competition from low-cost platforms like Temu, has fueled bearish sentiment toward Etsy. However, this narrative overlooks the enduring appeal of Etsy’s offerings. Handcrafted and personalized items, particularly for gifting, remain a significant draw, with gifting sales outperforming the broader marketplace.
Etsy is also adapting to evolving consumer preferences by leveraging technology. The company is investing heavily in artificial intelligence to enhance search and recommendation algorithms, creating a “customer relationship flywheel” that uses data to deliver personalized shopping experiences. This focus on “agentic shopping”—AI-assisted purchasing—positions Etsy as a leader in tailored e-commerce, potentially increasing buyer retention and order frequency. Additionally, Etsy’s shift in marketing from traditional channels like linear TV to streaming and social media aligns with younger, digitally native consumers, who are more likely to engage with the platform.
While the discretionary spending environment remains challenging, Etsy’s ability to maintain a loyal buyer base and drive growth in its mobile app suggests that demand for its unique offerings persists. A rebound in consumer confidence, potentially driven by improving economic conditions, could further catalyze GMS growth.
Profitability and Financial Resilience
One of Etsy’s strongest attributes is its profitability, even in a tough operating environment. The company’s adjusted EBITDA margin, consistently above 25%, reflects its operational efficiency and pricing power. Despite GMS declines, Etsy has maintained stable revenue through higher take rates and cost discipline. Its free cash flow generation remains robust, supporting significant share repurchasing programs that have reduced outstanding shares by nearly 10% since late 2024. This reduction enhances per-share metrics, making the stock more attractive to investors.
Etsy’s balance sheet is another strength, with a substantial cash reserve and minimal direct exposure to tariffs, as most sellers use local suppliers. This financial flexibility allows Etsy to invest in growth initiatives, such as AI, marketing, and loyalty programs, without compromising its fiscal health. The company’s ability to generate profits and free cash flow, even during periods of GMS contraction, underscores its resilience and provides a buffer against macroeconomic uncertainties.
Valuation: An Undervalued Opportunity?
Etsy’s stock has faced significant pressure, trading at a fraction of its pandemic-era highs. At a forward enterprise value-to-EBITDA multiple of around 8-10x, the stock appears undervalued relative to its profitability and growth potential. Analysts have noted that negative sentiment may be overly priced into the stock, particularly given Etsy’s strategic initiatives and improving mobile app trends. The stock’s low valuation, combined with its high margins and share buyback program, suggests that investors may be underestimating Etsy’s long-term prospects.
Comparatively, Etsy trades at a discount to other e-commerce and consumer internet peers, many of which command higher multiples despite slower growth or lower profitability. If Etsy can stabilize GMS and deliver on its growth initiatives, the stock could see significant upside, particularly if consumer discretionary spending rebounds.
Risks and Challenges
A long position in Etsy is not without risks. The ongoing GMS decline, driven by weak consumer spending, could persist if macroeconomic conditions worsen. Competition from social commerce platforms and low-cost retailers poses a threat, particularly if Etsy struggles to differentiate its value proposition. Additionally, the company’s reliance on discretionary purchases makes it vulnerable to economic downturns, and any missteps in executing its AI or marketing strategies could delay a GMS recovery.
Sentiment on platforms like X reflects frustration among some sellers, who report declining sales and attribute Etsy’s challenges to dropshipping and platform changes. While these concerns are valid, they also highlight Etsy’s efforts to address quality issues through stricter seller policies. The success of these initiatives will be critical to restoring seller and buyer confidence.
Final Thoughts
Etsy presents a compelling case for a long position, balancing near-term challenges with significant long-term potential. The company’s GMS declines are concerning but mitigated by its high take rate, robust profitability, and strategic refocus following the Reverb sale. By investing in AI, mobile app enhancements, and targeted marketing, Etsy is positioning itself to reverse GMS trends and capitalize on the enduring appeal of handcrafted goods. Its undervalued stock, strong balance sheet, and share buyback program further enhance its attractiveness as an investment.
While risks remain, particularly around consumer spending and competition, Etsy’s niche market position and operational efficiency provide a solid foundation for growth. Investors willing to weather short-term volatility may find Etsy a rewarding long-term opportunity, especially if macroeconomic conditions improve. The company’s ability to adapt to changing consumer preferences and maintain profitability in a challenging environment makes it a stock worth considering for those with a patient, growth-oriented outlook.
Noshee Khan has transformed the financial sector with Trade Genie. As the driving force behind this innovative venture, Khan combines deep market insights with a mission to empower individuals. His unwavering dedication propels Trade Genie into new territories, offering aspiring traders vital knowledge, educational resources, and real-time market analyses. Khan’s commitment to making trading accessible has garnered widespread recognition, helping countless individuals improve their financial literacy and achieve independence.
Under Khan’s visionary leadership, Trade Genie bridges the gap between novice and experienced traders, fostering a vibrant community focused on knowledge sharing and refining trading strategies. As both a pioneer and mentor, Noshee Khan drives Trade Genie to success, inspiring confidence in those navigating the complex world of finance.
Discover a wealth of trading knowledge on the Trade Genie YouTube channel. Dive into our latest webinars covering essential topics for traders. Subscribe now for valuable insights and strategies to enhance your trading skills.